academic-paper-reviewer

caixinyu2017-star/xixi

SkillLoads cleanly

Multi-perspective academic paper review with dynamic reviewer personas. Simulates 5 independent reviewers (EIC + 3 peer reviewers + Devil's Advocate) with…

Scores
out of 100 · grade B+

2026-08-06

Works

40% of the score

100/100

Loads cleanly: valid frontmatter, required fields present, no dangling references.

Maintained

25% of the score

94/100

no commits in the last 12 weeks
no license file

Adopted

20% of the score

4/100

1 stars on the source repo.

Documented

15% of the score

90/100

2,883 words with worked examples.
Ships 17 bundled files.

Loads cleanly. Every structural check Claude Code needs to register this passed. Last commit today.

Install

npx skills add caixinyu2017-star/xixi/academic-paper-reviewer

What the check found

Every finding on this listing, and what each one means for whether it loads.
Finding	What it means
No license	The repository ships no license file, so the reuse terms are unclear.

What it says it does

Multi-perspective academic paper review with dynamic reviewer personas. Simulates 5 independent reviewers (EIC + 3 peer reviewers + Devil's Advocate) with field-specific expertise. Supports full review, re-review (verification), quick assessment, methodology focus, and Socratic guided modes. Triggers on: review paper, peer review, manuscript review, referee report, review my paper, critique paper, simulate review, editorial review.

Every number above came out of reading the file and its repository. Nothing is a judgement call, nothing is a model’s opinion, and nothing can be paid for. The full method is published. Source last committed 2026-08-06.

Also in caixinyu2017-star/xixi

Other artifacts published from the same repository.
Artifact	What the check found	Type	Reach	Last commit
bayesian-workflowcaixinyu2017-star/xixi	No license	Skill	1 stars	today
paper-auditcaixinyu2017-star/xixi	No license	Skill	1 stars	today
empirical-playbookcaixinyu2017-star/xixi	No license	Skill	1 stars	today
education-data-source-mepscaixinyu2017-star/xixi	No license	Skill	1 stars	today
latex-to-quartocaixinyu2017-star/xixi	No license	Skill	1 stars	today
citation-verificationcaixinyu2017-star/xixi	No license	Skill	1 stars	today

Other code review skills

Browse all

Same category, same type, ranked by score.
Artifact	What the check found	Category	Reach	Last commit
receiving-code-reviewobra/superpowers	clean	Code review	173,412 installs	2 days ago
scaffold-exercisesmattpocock/skills	clean	Code review	241,781 installs	today
financial-statementsanthropics/knowledge-work-plugins	clean	Code review	3,719 installs	today
review-contractanthropics/knowledge-work-plugins	clean	Code review	3,017 installs	today
backport-prvercel/next.js	clean	Code review	142k stars	today
create-prvercel/next.js	clean	Code review	142k stars	today

Put this measurement in your README

A badge carrying how many listings this index holds from the repository and how many pass every static structural check. It reads from this index every time somebody loads your page, so it changes when the measurement changes and there is nothing to keep up to date. Free, no account, and the value is not something you or we can set by hand.

[![SkillWorks](https://toolproof.kynth.studio/badge/skillworks/caixinyu2017-star/xixi.svg)](https://skillworks.kynth.studio/?q=caixinyu2017-star%2Fxixi)

Would rather not hotlink us? Every badge is also served in shields.io’s endpoint schema, so shields renders the image and your readers never talk to our domain:

Published by Toolproof, the masthead over this index and eight others. The method behind the number is at toolproof.kynth.studio/methodology, and the whole thing is readable as JSON with no key at /api.